Built in 1825, the historic Colonel David Petrie House is an extraordinary survivor in Little Falls, offering more than two centuries of architectural character for $360,000.
Federal influences remain at the heart of the residence, while later additions tell the story of how the house evolved across generations.
Its sweeping curved bay, stately façade, and remarkable two-level porch create an impressive first impression, leading into a grand foyer with a graceful curved staircase and chandelier.
528 Garden St, Little Falls, New York — $360,000
6 bedrooms | 2.5 baths | 4,260 sq. ft. | Built 1825 | 0.35 acres | Colonel David Petrie House
Inside, a music room features French doors, a bay window, pocket doors, and porch access, while the library combines built-in shelving, leaded glass, and one of the home’s five fireplaces.
The formal dining room includes another fireplace and glass-front cabinetry, while the spacious living room features a bay window, built-ins, gas fireplace, and additional porch access.
Upstairs are six bedrooms, including two primary suites with en-suite baths, one distinguished by a glass-tiled fireplace decorated with classical portraits. Beyond the main living spaces, a massive attic offers possibilities for a loft, artist studio, or creative retreat, while the fenced backyard conceals mature trees, gardens, and a beautiful koi pond with a waterfall.
After previously being offered at higher prices, the property returned to the market in September 2026 at $360,000, making its substantial scale and architectural history especially noteworthy. For a buyer who values genuine early-American architecture, original craftsmanship, and a home with a story stretching back to the first half of the nineteenth century, the Colonel David Petrie House offers a rare opportunity to become the next steward of a truly distinctive piece of Little Falls history.
Listed by: Coldwell Banker Faith Properties 315-735-2222, Alicia Collver 315-794-2994