A Remarkable 1880 Victorian Mansion known as the “The Gingerbread House”

Located at 1274 State Route 40, along the historic National Road, the mansion dates to 1880 and is recognized on the National Register of Historic Places, according to the listing. Now offered for $399,900, it features five bedrooms, three full bathrooms, and one half bathroom across approximately 4,015 square feet.

A Victorian Exterior Filled With Remarkable Detail

The mansion’s exterior immediately captures attention. Its dramatic tower, elaborate gingerbread detailing, ornate window surrounds, and decorative trim create the kind of intricate architectural appearance that makes late-19th-century homes so distinctive.

The grand wraparound porch adds to its impressive presence, providing a welcoming outdoor space and a wonderful place to appreciate the home’s surroundings. Its three-story design and distinctive roofline give the property a commanding appearance along the historic National Road.

The listing attributes the home’s original craftsmanship to prominent local craftsman Robert Porter, adding another interesting chapter to its story.

Parlors and Traditional Living Spaces

Step inside, and the Victorian character continues through a series of beautifully appointed rooms. The home features a stunning parlor, a spacious living room, and an elegant formal dining room, each offering a generous setting for entertaining and everyday living.

Intricate period details help preserve the atmosphere of the historic interior, while hardwood flooring and ceramic tile add warmth and texture throughout the home.

Two gas fireplaces provide additional character and create inviting focal points within the living spaces.

An Updated Kitchen With Modern Convenience

The kitchen blends contemporary functionality with the home’s traditional character. Its updated design includes modern appliances and practical preparation space, making it suitable for everyday cooking as well as entertaining.

The main floor also includes a den, offering another flexible living area. A lower-level laundry room adds convenience, while the home’s full walk-out basement provides additional storage and utility space.

Five Bedrooms Across the Upper Floors

The second and third floors accommodate five bedrooms and three full bathrooms, along with a half bathroom elsewhere in the home. The spacious upper-level rooms provide flexibility for family members, guests, or a combination of sleeping and working spaces.

The three-story layout gives the residence an impressive amount of interior space while maintaining the traditional arrangement associated with historic Victorian homes.

A Generous Backyard Along the Historic National Road

Outside, the property includes a level backyard with inviting outdoor spaces and off-street parking for up to four vehicles, according to the current listing.

The combined lot is reported at approximately 4,965 square feet in the current Redfin listing, although an earlier listing record described a larger combined lot. Buyers should confirm the precise parcel boundaries and lot size.

The home’s location along the historic National Road offers a connection to one of the region’s important historic routes, while Claysville provides a quieter small-town setting with access to Washington and the greater Pittsburgh area.

A Piece of Pennsylvania’s Victorian Heritage

For those of us who appreciate historic homes, the Montgomery Mansion offers more than impressive square footage. Its dramatic tower, ornate gingerbread details, wraparound porch, elegant parlors, and three-story layout preserve the distinctive architectural personality of the Victorian era.

Recognized on the National Register of Historic Places, this residence represents an opportunity to own a notable piece of Western Pennsylvania’s architectural heritage.

Listed at $399,900, the Gingerbread House is a distinctive property for anyone drawn to historic craftsmanship, grand Victorian interiors, and homes with stories to tell.

🏡 Property Details

📍 Address: 1274 State Route 40, Claysville, PA 15323
💰 Asking Price: $399,900
🔑 Status: Listed for sale as of October 29, 2026
📅 Year Built: 1880
🛏️ Bedrooms: 5
🛁 Bathrooms: 3 full and 1 half
📐 Living Area: 4,015 square feet
🌳 Lot Size: 4,965 square feet (current listing)
🏛️ Historic Name: Montgomery Mansion / The Gingerbread House
🏠 Architectural Style: Victorian
📜 Historic Recognition: Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, according to the listing
🗼 Exterior Features: Mansard-roofed tower, gingerbread detailing, ornate window surrounds, wraparound porch
🔥 Fireplaces: 2 gas fireplaces
🪵 Interior Features: Victorian period details, hardwood and ceramic tile flooring, formal parlor and dining room
🍽️ Kitchen: Updated kitchen with modern appliances
🌿 Outdoor Features: Level backyard and inviting outdoor spaces
🚗 Parking: Off-street parking for up to 4 vehicles
🏠 Additional Features: Three stories, full walk-out basement, lower-level laundry room
📋 MLS Number: 1781286