Step into the romance of a bygone era at 202 Main Street in Cooperstown, where this beautifully preserved Victorian home, built in 1893, has been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated over generations.
Offered at $529,000, this enchanting residence features 4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and approximately 2,232 square feet of living space on a 9,583-square-foot lot, all within walking distance of Cooperstown’s most treasured destinations.
Adorned with exquisite gingerbread trim, the home radiates classic Victorian charm from the moment you arrive. For more than 40 years, it has been known as the beloved Main Street B&B, welcoming guests from near and far.
Its longtime proprietors cultivated a devoted following, with many visitors returning year after year for the home’s unforgettable, famously indulgent breakfasts and warm hospitality.
Inside, original period details shine throughout, including stunning natural woodwork and elegant pocket doors in the spacious double living room—an inviting setting for gatherings, celebrations, or cozy evenings at home.
The dining room opens directly to a vine-draped sitting porch, creating a magical outdoor nook perfect for morning coffee or relaxed evenings with friends and family.
The main level is both charming and practical, offering a full bathroom, a rear mudroom entry, extra pantry space, and a delightful enclosed three-season room that serves as a peaceful retreat throughout much of the year.
Upstairs, you’ll find three bedrooms, three bathrooms, and an additional flexible room ideal for a home office, study, or creative space.
A stairway leads to the full attic, featuring floored storage, a half bath, and even more potential—perfect for a den, studio, or hobby room.
The full basement provides abundant storage and workspace, while the impressive two-story carriage barn at the rear of the property includes a two-car garage and an upper level accessible by stairway, ideal for storage, a workshop, or future expansion.
The backyard offers a peaceful, open canvas for gardening, play, or outdoor entertaining, adding to the home’s welcoming atmosphere.
Best of all, this property is within easy walking distance of Cooperstown’s most iconic attractions, including the Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake, Fenimore Farm, and the Fenimore Art Museum.
Ready for its next chapter, this lovingly cared-for Victorian offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Cooperstown’s history—whether as a private residence, an investment, or a continuation of its legacy of hospitality.
🏛️ Beautifully Preserved Victorian | Built 1893
📍 202 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
💰 $529,000
🛏️ 4 Bedrooms
🛁 5 Bathrooms
📐 2,232 Sq Ft
🌳 9,583 Sq Ft Lot
🍽️ Formerly the beloved Main Street B&B — welcoming guests for over 40 years
💖 Renowned for its unforgettable, indulgent breakfasts & loyal returning visitors
🎀 Stunning gingerbread trim & late-1800s Victorian charm
🪵 Original natural woodwork throughout
🚪 Elegant pocket doors in the double living room — perfect for gatherings
🍷 Dining room opens to a vine-draped sitting porch
☕ Magical spot for morning coffee or relaxed evenings
🛁 Main-level full bath, rear mudroom entry & extra pantry space
🌿 Charming enclosed three-season room
🛏️ Upper level features 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, plus a flexible bonus room
🪜 Stairway to a full attic with floored storage, half bath & space for a den or studio
🏗️ Full basement with abundant storage & workspace
🚗 Spacious two-story carriage barn
🚙 Two-car garage + upper level ideal for storage, workshop, or future expansion
🌸 Peaceful backyard ready for gardening, play, or outdoor entertaining
📍 Walk to Cooperstown’s most treasured attractions:
⚾ Baseball Hall of Fame
🌊 Otsego Lake
🌾 Fenimore Farm
🖼️ Fenimore Art Museum
📞 Listing by: DON OLIN REALTY INC
👤 Margaret Savoie
From Zillow 
