You can feel the history here. Driving down a winding country road in Chester, this 1840 Colonial sits on its three acres with a quiet dignity that only time can bestow. This isn’t a modern imitation; it’s a genuine survivor from the pre-Civil War era, a tangible piece of the Hudson Valley’s past waiting for its next steward.
For anyone who appreciates the solid, honest-to-goodness architecture of the 19th century, this home has the bones we’re always looking for. The layout is wonderfully generous, with five full bedrooms and ample living space that speaks to a time of large families and gatherings. It has that unmistakable feeling of a home that has been loved and lived in for nearly two centuries.
What’s so appealing here is that this isn’t a neglected relic requiring a bottomless budget. The essential, expensive work that protects a house from the elements—the roof, siding, and windows—is in good shape. It’s a solid, sturdy starting point. The home is clean and ready to be lived in while you dream.
This is a house for someone with a vision. It’s for the person who wants to choose their own finishes, to lovingly restore rather than renovate, and to put their own stamp on a historic property. Yes, there are projects—the central air needs attention and the old in-ground pool is a blank canvas for a future summer oasis. But these are the manageable tasks that allow you to build real value and tailor the home to your life.
Set on over three level acres with mature trees, it offers the space and serenity of true country living. It’s a rare opportunity to take on a significant historic home with so much land, without the staggering price tag of a fully restored estate. This is your chance to be the one who brings it into its next glorious chapter.
For Sale – 19th Century Colonial
$499,000
358 Bull Mill Road, Chester, NY 10918
5 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
3,120 Sqft of Living Space
3.1 Acres Lot
Built in 1840 – Historic Colonial Charm
