Claysville’s “Gingerbread House” Listed for $399,900
A mansard-roofed tower, decorative gingerbread trim, and wraparound porch distinguish the Montgomery Mansion in Claysville, Pennsylvania. Known in the listing as “The Gingerbread House,” the residence at 1274 State Route 40 W is offered for $399,900. The current Zillow listing reports 4,015 square feet, five bedrooms, and three full bathrooms plus one half bathroom, with a recorded construction year of 1880.
Victorian Details Across Three Stories
The exterior’s ornate window surrounds and elaborate trim give the house a distinctive appearance along the historic National Road. Inside, the brokerage description highlights parlors, separate living and dining rooms, and period detailing. An updated kitchen adds modern convenience, while hardwood and ceramic-tile flooring appear in the specifications. Two gas fireplaces are also listed.
All five bedrooms are upstairs, with bedrooms and bathrooms spread across the second and third floors. The primary bedroom measures a listed 22 by 12 feet, and the other bedrooms range from 15 by 15 feet to 16 by 16 feet. The main floor includes separate family and living rooms, giving the house several places to gather or spend time quietly. Laundry facilities are on the lower level, which includes a full basement with walk-out access.
Outdoor Space and Practical Features
The marketing description refers to a combined double lot, a level backyard, and off-street parking with a carport. However, the published lot figure is 4,965 square feet, so buyers should confirm the total land and parcels included. The Redfin property specifications list parking for four vehicles, public water and sewer, gas hot-water heating, and wall or window air-conditioning units. The roof is listed as metal.
🏡 Property Details
- 📍 Address: 1274 State Route 40 W, Claysville, PA 15323
- 💵 Asking price: $399,900
- 📋 Status: Active when checked November 10, 2026
- 🗓️ Listed year built: 1880
- 🛏️ Bedrooms: 5
- 🛁 Bathrooms: 3 full and 1 half
- 📐 Living area: 4,015 square feet
- 🌳 Published lot size: 4,965 square feet; confirm combined-lot total
- 🏛️ Style: Victorian, three stories
- 🔥 Fireplaces: 2 gas
- 🚗 Parking: 4 off-street spaces; carport described
- 🏫 School district: McGuffey
- 🔑 MLS: 1781286
Listed by:
John Fincham 724-222-5500,
Keller Williams Realty 724-222-5500

