Second Empire Victorian: c. 1874 Historic Landmark

Built in 1874, 440 Park Avenue is an imposing three-story Victorian residence that combines dramatic presence with remarkably preserved craftsmanship.

Listed by: Realty One Group Supreme 570-392-9806, Becky Birdsall 607-240-9404

Inside, ornate woodwork, soaring ceilings, hardwood floors, and six fireplaces create the kind of richly detailed interiors that have become increasingly difficult to find in modern homes.

The expansive floor plan offers six bedrooms, formal living and dining spaces, a library, home-office possibilities, and more than 3,500 square feet of finished living space.

A covered front porch reinforces the home’s grand exterior, while the generous 0.42-acre in-town lot provides an attractive setting for this imposing piece of Waverly’s architectural heritage.

440 Park Ave, Waverly, New York — $375,000

6 beds • 2.5 baths • 3,569 sq. ft. • Built 1874 • 0.42 acres • Victorian

Behind the house, a detached three-car garage and workshop adds valuable utility and could provide space for vehicles, collections, hobbies, or future creative projects.

The property has undergone extensive restoration and updates intended to preserve its architectural integrity while improving modern functionality, and original blueprints and historical documents are included with the sale—an unusually tangible connection to the home’s past.

After being offered at higher prices earlier in 2026, the Victorian is now listed at $375,000 following another $4,000 reduction in August.

For a buyer drawn to houses with personality, 440 Park Avenue offers the chance to inhabit a genuine 19th-century Victorian—complete with dramatic rooms, six fireplaces, original craftsmanship, and the very documents that help tell its story.